Skip to content

Unreal Engine vs. Unity for Virtual Production and VFX

Screenshot of the Quixel Bridge interface

Disclosure: Some of the links in this article may be affiliate links, which can provide compensation to us at no cost to you. You can read our full affiliate disclosure in our privacy policy.

In the realm of virtual production and visual effects (VFX), two game engines stand out: Unity and Unreal Engine. Both are powerful tools that offer a wealth of features for filmmakers and VFX artists. But which one is the right choice for your project? In this article, we’ll compare the key features of Unity and Unreal Engine to help you make an informed decision.

Overview

Unity and Unreal Engine are both advanced game engines that have been adapted for uses far beyond gaming. They offer real-time rendering capabilities, a wide range of tools and features, and the ability to create stunning visuals. However, they each have their strengths and weaknesses, and the best choice depends on your specific needs and preferences.

Comparison of Unreal Engine and Unity

Let’s compare Unity and Unreal Engine across several key areas:

Platforms

Both Unity and Unreal Engine support a wide range of platforms, including Windows, Mac, and Linux. However, Linux installation for Unreal Engine is a manual process.

In terms of gaming and releasing games and applications, both Unity and Unreal Engine offer multi-platform support, meaning they can be used to develop games and applications for a variety of platforms, including Windows, Mac, Linux, iOS, Android, and various game consoles.

However, Unity is often considered to have a slight edge in this area. It supports more than 25 platforms and is particularly well-regarded for its comprehensive mobile support. While offering broad platform support, Unreal Engine is sometimes considered less optimal for mobile game development due to its higher system requirements.

Winner: Tie


Cost

Both engines offer free versions, but their pricing models differ.

Unity operates on a tiered subscription model, with different pricing for personal, plus, pro, and enterprise levels. The cost ranges from free for the personal plan (for hobbyists and beginners) to $200 per month for the enterprise plan (for large businesses).

Unreal Engine, on the other hand, is free to use with all features included. However, if you’re making a game or application and that project earns more than $1 million, you’ll need to pay a 5% royalty to Epic Games. In terms of VFX and filmmaking, Unreal Engine is 100% free, however, there is an option available to pay for personalized support and training.

Winner: Unreal Engine


Ease of Use

When it comes to ease of use, Unity is often considered the more beginner-friendly of the two engines. Its interface is simpler and more intuitive, and it uses C# for scripting, which is generally considered easier to learn than Unreal Engine’s C++.

Unreal Engine, while offering more advanced features and capabilities, can be more complex and intimidating for beginners. Its visual scripting system, Blueprint, allows for game development without writing code, but getting to grips with the system can still be challenging for those new to game development.

Winner: Unreal Engine


Performance

Both Unity and Unreal Engine are high-performance engines capable of creating complex and detailed virtual environments.

However, Unreal Engine is often considered to have the edge when it comes to graphical fidelity and real-time rendering capabilities. Its advanced lighting and shading systems can create highly realistic visuals, making it the more popular choice for AAA game development, VFX and film production.

Winner: Unreal Engine


Graphics

Unreal Engine is renowned for its ability to create high-quality, photorealistic graphics. It offers advanced lighting, shading, and particle systems, and its real-time rendering capabilities are some of the best in the industry.

Unity, while also capable of creating beautiful graphics, is often seen as more suited to stylized or cartoonish visuals. However, with the introduction of the High Definition Render Pipeline (HDRP), Unity has significantly improved its capabilities for high-fidelity visuals.

Winner: Unreal Engine


Animation

Both Unity and Unreal Engine offer robust animation tools. Unity’s animation system is flexible and powerful, allowing for a wide range of animation styles. It also integrates well with popular animation software like Maya and Blender.

Unreal Engine’s animation system is equally powerful, and its Sequencer tool is a standout feature. Sequencer is a multi-track editor that allows for film-style sequencing and editing, making it a popular choice for filmmakers and cinematics.

Winner: Unreal Engine


User Experience

Unity’s user interface is generally considered more intuitive and user-friendly, particularly for beginners. Its layout is straightforward and easy to navigate, and it offers a high degree of customization.

Unreal Engine’s user interface is more complex, offering a vast array of tools and settings. While this complexity allows for a greater depth of control and customization, it can be overwhelming for new users. However, once mastered, the interface offers a powerful suite of tools at your fingertips.

Winner: Unity


Quality of Support

Both Unity and Unreal Engine have large and active user communities, which can be avaluable resource for troubleshooting and learning new techniques. Unity’s larger user base often means it’s easier to find help and resources online. There are countless tutorials, forums, and online courses available to help you overcome any challenges you might encounter.

Unreal Engine also has a strong community, and Epic Games provides extensive documentation and learning resources. However, some users find that the community is slightly less active than Unity’s, which can sometimes make it harder to find solutions to specific problems.

In terms of official support, both companies offer professional support services. Unity offers priority queue support to subscribers of their Plus and Pro plans, while Epic Games provides direct support to subscribers of their Unreal Engine Pro plan.

Winner: Unity


Included Assets

When it comes to included assets, Unreal Engine has a significant advantage. In 2019, Epic Games acquired Quixel, the company behind Megascans, a vast library of high-quality 3D photogrammetry assets. As part of this acquisition, all Megascans assets were made free for all Unreal Engine users. This means that Unreal Engine users have free access to thousands of high-quality, real-world assets to use in their projects, providing a huge boost to the speed and quality of environment creation.

Unity, on the other hand, does not include a comparable asset library. Unity users can purchase assets from the Unity Asset Store, which includes a wide variety of assets from Unity and community members. While the Unity Asset Store is extensive, it does not offer the same level of quality and consistency as the Megascans library.

The inclusion of Megascans with Unreal Engine is a significant benefit, particularly for filmmakers and developers working on projects that require realistic environments. It can save a significant amount of time and resources in asset creation and allows artists to focus more on the creative aspects of their projects.

Winner: Unreal Engine


Conclusion

Unreal Engine is the best option for most users in terms of visual effects, virtual production, and filmmaking. It provides high-quality graphics, advanced cinematic tools, or prefer a deeper level of control.

Unity might be the better choice if you don’t need photorealistic renders or you are creating a stylized project. It is easier to learn if you’re a beginner, provides broad platform support, includes a more intuitive user interface, and has better user support.

Remember, the best way to decide is to try both engines and see which one feels right for you. Both offer free versions, so you can experiment and find the best fit for your project.

Share this post on social